|
REASONS FOR MISINTERPRETING THE QUR'AN
Prejudice, Ulterior Motives and Lack of Sincerity
It is impossible to understand the Qur'an if one approaches
it with ulterior motives and prejudice. This is a law of God. No matter
how clever and cultured a person may be, if he views the Qur'an with an
insincere and concealed intent, he will not be able understand or interpret
it correctly, and will reach many false conclusions. That is why, according
to the Qur'an, an "obscuring veil" will form between someone
with a prejudiced and calculating approach and the Qur'an. This fact is
mentioned in Qur'anic verses:
When you recite the Qur'an, We place an obscuring
veil between you and those who do not believe in the hereafter. We have
placed covers on their hearts, preventing them from understanding it,
and heaviness in their ears. When you mention your Lord alone in the Qur'an,
they turn their backs and run away. (Surat al-Isra': 45-46)
The Qur'an is an invitation to the right path for the whole of mankind,
but God it is only understood properly
by believers. The most important qualities of believers, that allow them
to understand the Qur'an, are their good consciences and sincerity. It
is only natural for people who are distant from religious morality and whose spiritual
state and character are far from those of a believer, to misunderstand
the Qur'an.
The Qur'an is written in a very clear, simple and understandable language
but, as we have already stated, it is a book that is only clear to those
believers with a pure conscience. If anyone who has not been introduced
to Islam yet, in other words who is still a non-believer, approaches the
Qur'an wholeheartedly, sincerely and without prejudice, which are the
traits of a believer, he will be able to realize by the use of his conscience
that it is the word of God. Everyone of good conscience would accept that
the Qur'an, whether from the magnificence of its style, its perfection
and clarity or from its superior scientific contents and wisdom, does
not represent the words of a man but is instead a holy book. If such a
conscientious person expresses faith and tries to comprehend the Qur'an,
then its wisdom will become apparent to him. God's messenger, the Prophet
Muhammad (saas), also referred to this in a hadith:
Abdur Rahman bin Abi Bakra's father narrated that the
Prophet (saas) said: "If God wants to do good to a person, he makes
him comprehend the religion and of course knowledge is attained by learning."
(Bukhari 1/67)
The Qur'an will guide someone with a humble heart to salvation, while
it will misguide those who harbour ulterior motives and are hostile to
it. No one who uses misguided information, interpretations, lies and prejudices
taken from others, together with his own false principles, world-view and philosophy
of life, as yardsticks can either understand the Qur'an nor benefit from
it. In fact, just the opposite applies; the Qur'an will simply increase
such a person's perversion and confusion. As he is unable to understand
the Qur'an, he will raise foolish and illogical objections and twisted,
nonsensical interpretations. As stated in the verse, "... it (the
Qur'an) only increases the wrongdoers in loss" (Surat Al Isra': 82)
he will be distant from the Qur'an and faith.
We will compare the foolish comments made by these imprudent people about
some of the Qur'anic verses with their correct meanings and interpretations
in the next chapters.
Confusing Intricate (Mutashabih) Verses With Perspicuous (Muhkam) Ones
The Qur'anic commandments have been explained in a clear and simple manner
so believers can easily abide by them. These are called the "perspicuous"
(muhkam) verses. These verses, according to the Qur'an, are the "Core
of the Book" and so make up its foundation. There is another type
of Qur'anic verses that are referred to as "intricate" (mutashabih)
verses. These types of verses contain various comparisons and similes.
People with no Qur'anic knowledge but ulterior motives can misinterpret
the "intricate verses" in many twisted and startling ways. This
is explained in the Qur'an as follows:
It is He Who sent down the Book to you from Him:
verses containing clear judgements – they are the core of the Book – and
others which are open to interpretation. Those with deviation in their
hearts follow what is open to interpretation in it, desiring conflict,
seeking its inner meaning. No one knows its inner meaning but God. Those
firmly rooted in knowledge say, 'We have faith in it. All of it is from
our Lord.' But only people of intelligence pay heed. (Surat Al 'Imran:
7)
God alone knows the meanings of "intricate verses." Throughout
history there have been perverted people, sects and movements that have
interpreted the "intricate" Qur'anic verses in order to serve
their own twisted aims and expectations. It is stated in this verse that
this is sedition and that only people with misguided hearts, and more
specifically those who have deviated from the right path, would resort
to such methods.
The fact that only God knows the true meanings of these intricate verses
is also made clear in the verse. God can reveal the information necessary
for the interpretation of these verses to whomever He pleases. However,
believers accept all of these intricate verses, the knowledge of which
has not been revealed to them. They would never stoop to making perverted
interpretations like those who wish to see conflict and whose hearts are
twisted.
STATEMENTS BY BEDIUZZAMAN SAID NURSI CONCERNING THE VERSES AND HADITHS OPEN TO INTERPRETATION
Bediuzzaman Said Nursi says that the meanings of verses open to interpretation resemble the roots of a tree that are invisible beneath the ground and that these statements are a great blessing from our omniscient Lord:
The verses of the Qur’an have meanings that expand in the form of interconnected circles. These are circles that do not intersect but that have the same centers—just in the same way that increasingly expanding circles form around a stone thrown into a still pond. The true central meaning is the obvious meaning, while the others are increasingly expanding intentions. Or they are like the concentric circles in a tree trunk. The broader the trunk of the tree, the more valuable it is. When we look from the outside we see the trunk and branches. But it also has deep, thick roots and thousands of vessels that go even deeper. The verses of the Qur’an also have surface, depth, roots and vessels. (Letters, 502)
As Bediuzzaman says, these more obscure meanings in the Qur’an and the hadith can be explained and interpreted by Islamic scholars in many different ways. One of the subjects to which Said Nursi attaches the greatest importance is the way that similes in verses and hadith can be elaborated on in different ways. Both verses and hadith are interpreted in different ways in the Risale-i Nur collection. Indeed, Bediuzzaman sometimes interprets one single hadith in 15-20 different ways. These words of his are highly significant in terms of allegorical knowledge:
... But Hadiths contain certain allegorical obscurities like the Qur’an. Only the elite can ascertain their meanings. (Twenty-Eighth Letter-Second Matter, p. 414)
The allegories are part of fine and difficult metaphors. In fact allegories are those visible aspects that indicate finer truths. (Isharat-ul I'jaz, 170)
In these words, Bediuzzaman Said Nursi notes what an important and necessary task it is for the verses of the Qur’an and the hadith to be interpreted in different ways by Islamic scholars.
Bediuzzaman frequently emphasizes in the Risale-i Nur collection that Islamic scholars have an important responsibility to ensure that hadith and verses open to interpretation are properly understood. In the following extract from the Letters, Bediuzzaman says that the verses of the Qur’an have interconnected, layered meanings, and that these need to be expounded by Islamic scholars, commentators and wise people:
The phrases of the All-Wise Qur’an are not restricted to a single meaning; rather since the Qur’an addresses all the levels of mankind, its phrases are like universals or wholes which comprise meanings for each level. The meanings which are expounded are like the parts of the general law. Every Qur’anic commentator, every adept, mentions one part of the whole. Based on either his illumination, or his proofs, or his way, he prefers one meaning… Any of these may be intended or meant, and may be their literal and metaphorical meanings. (Letters / Twenty Sixth Letter, Fourth Topic, p. 388)
As Bediuzzaman says, verses and hadith with a hidden meaning attain a new life by being expounded by Islamic scholars and other knowledgeable experts, but each meaning is regarded as part of a whole.
In one passage Bediuzzaman Said Nursi says that the verses of the Qur’an also contain many references to the future and to scientific advances. He says that our Lord has imparted these references in an indirect manner, but that they can be fully revealed through interpretations by Islamic scholars:
I have understood the wisdom in the use of these possible statements in the Qur’an. But should there not have been a reference to truths in the universe while aiming to guide human beings to believe in one and only Allah? Qur’an has revealed signs and indications in order to guide scholars to the truth. For example, while it is not openly stated that the Earth rotates, other verses contain references to it being spherical and revolving.
... the words of the Qur’an have been positioned in such a way that all its phrases, words, even, and even letters, and sometimes even an omission, has many aspects. It gives to all those it addresses their share from a different door. (The Words / Twenty-Fifth Word-First Light-Second Ray, p.403)
As Bediuzzaman also states, many of the scientific miracles in the verses of the Qur’an are set out using veiled descriptions. These miracles have been interpreted by Islamic scholars, and it has thus been revealed that many scientific advances that have only been found out recently actually appeared in the Qur’an 1400 years ago.
STATEMENTS BY HAMDI YAZIR OF ELMALI CONCERNING THE MEANINGS OF VERSES AND HADITHS OPEN TO INTERPRETATION
The great Islamic scholar and commentator Muhammad Hamdi Yazır of Elmali also emphasizes in his own writings the interpretation of allegorical verses. This is how he describes how such accounts contain many meanings and their importance and value in elucidating a subject:
An allegorical statement is not something meaningless that has been overlooked. On the contrary, since they contain many meanings and it is impossible for us to determine the essential significance, they may appear to be unclear to some people. An allegory is actually a statement that brings many different references together. These include true and figurative meanings, explicit and indirect remarks, representation and investigation, superficial and hidden references... Hiding the meaning may sometimes be regarded as one of the most valuable elements of a statement. Since not every word is addressed to every person, so mankind in general is unable to comprehend all the knowledge of Allah. (M. Hamdi Yazir, Hak Dini Kur'an Dili, Istanbul, 1935, 1,48)
Not Knowing How to Interpret the Qur'an
The Qur'an is a miraculous Book that contains all of the essential information
mankind needs. This is due to the endless Divine wisdom present in it.
A finite number of verses contain infinite knowledge that has been placed
in them with superior wisdom. The verses contain meanings that may be
apparent, hidden, inter-woven or overlapping. They also produce countless
other meanings when they interact with other verses. There are times when
a single verse can take a whole book to explain. That is why, in order
to be able to interpret the Qur'an correctly and take in all of its contents,
one must be capable of grasping it in its entirety and must also know the ways Islamic scholars followed on this matter.
One significant way consists of analyzing a verse according to
its context in the Qur'an. The meaning of a Qur'anic verse can often be
explained according to the theme around it. The way a verse begins and
those verses which follow it help to clarify its meaning. This topic is
referred to in Islamic literature as the verse's "Sibaq u Siyaq"
or "the whole context of a word". This is the reason why many
of the verses can be misinterpreted if they are taken out and translated
only in terms of the words they consist of and without any regard to their
entire context.
Such misinterpretation of the Qur'anic verses throughout history, whether
due to ignorance or perverted intent, has resulted in misunderstanding
of the Qur'an, and certain groups with ulterior motives have even slandered
it.
Another important way is to try to understand the words that make up the verses
by taking their context in that particular verse into consideration. Much
Qur'anic vocabulary has specially intended meanings. The meaning of one
Qur'anic word often derives from the way it is used in another part of
the Qur'an. Time and again a word can have more than one meaning. So the
meaning of such a word is to be deduced from the manner in which it is
used in a different section of the Qur'an. Just looking the word up in
a dictionary and applying the first meaning we come across can result
in an extremely inaccurate interpretation; and sometimes, the interpretation
that results can even be the opposite of the true meaning. One can see
from this that the Qur'an is self-explanatory. The explanation of one
verse can sometimes be hidden in the meaning of another verse or verses.
Another important rule in the interpretation of the Qur'an is to fully
grasp its essence. In order to do that, one has to see it as a whole.
Furthermore, it should be explained in the light of the many verses which
reflect the infinite mercy, compassion and justice of God.
One highly important matter is for Muslims not to draw conclusions from the Qur’an in their own interpretations and evaluations. A sincere Muslim must follow the expositions of Islamic scholars on this subject and act according to their knowledgeable statements.
Since the Qur'an is a Divine book it is quite unlike any other book and
should never be compared to them. The Qur'an has a unique style. One has
to grasp the overall style along with its underlying essence to do justice
to the explanations, particularly when reading the "intricate"
verses. It is important to adopt a wider perspective and cover the intensely
spiritual aspects of the Qur'an to be able to properly understand the
various facts revealed by God.
Insufficient Knowledge of Arabic
God states that He has sent the Qur'an as a book written in Arabic. Obviously, translations into other languages are necessary to understand the verses, to learn about God, the main principles of faith and their essential applications, as well as to seek guidance and meditate on it. Nonetheless, none of these translations can, in any way, match the original language of the Qur'an. Even in a direct, word for word translation, a lot of vocabulary as well as meanings will be missed since it is quite impossible to grammatically adapt many Arabic words in their correct sentence form to any other language. Therefore, so-called "translations of the Qur'an" do no more than give an overall feel of its contents and never actually reflect the exact meanings of the verses.
Therefore unless the Qur'an is studied in its original language, Arabic, one's ability to comprehend its wisdom will be severely limited. Trying to explain Qur'anic verses from translations in other languages may not always be accurate, and in fact, could even distort its meanings and intention. Relying on single or equivalent meanings of the words used in translations, without knowing their original and various other meanings in Arabic, could result in misunderstanding the whole verse. Even worse, an interpretation entirely at odds with the original meanings could result.
As we mentioned earlier, it is technically impossible to translate the Qur'an into another language on a word for word basis. Nonetheless, explanations and interpretations of the Qur'anic verses can, of course, be made in other languages, and it may indeed be possible to understand the Qur'an and learn about its verses from them. The reference source to which Muslims must apply is the translations and commentaries written by Islamic scholars.
Arabic is one of the deepest-rooted and richest languages in the world. It is powerfully expressive and has an extensive vocabulary. However, to claim that because of the language it is written in, the Qur'an has only been sent to Arabs and that they are therefore the chosen people, would be an assumption at odds with the morals of the Qur'an. It is a well-known fact the Qur'an emphasizes that the only criteria that constitute superiority are fear of God (taqwa) and a person's closeness to God, and that no criteria other than these apply. Furthermore, it is stated in Surah Sad verse 87 that the Qur'an is "a reminder for all peoples." People whose aims are to influence the ignorant and, in their own eyes, try to destroy Islam make claims such that Islam is a religion only for Arabs. This is of course a fruitless endeavor. Besides, it is sufficient to read the Qur'an to realize just how baseless and deliberate such ideas are.
The Absence of God-Given Wisdom and Understanding
It is stated in the verses of the Qur'an that one has to have the wisdom,
understanding and comprehension provided by God in order to discover its
correct meanings. God's messenger, the Prophet Muhammad (saas), also mentioned
this in a hadith:
Abdullah bin Umar narrated that God's Messenger (saas) said, "Do
not wish to be like anybody except in two cases: The case of a man whom
God has given wealth and he spends it in the right way; and that of
a man whom God has given religious wisdom (i.e., Qur'an and Sunnah)
and he gives his verdicts according to it, and teaches it to others."
(Bukhari 9/419 and 6/543)
The essentials necessary to understand the Qur'an are total knowledge of the Qur'an, proper interpretation, and having extensive Arabic skills. Nonetheless, even if one possesses all these one still cannot benefit from the Qur'an unless one has God's gift of understanding. This is why it is not sufficient to possess only the necessary technical knowledge to correctly interpret the Qur'an. History is full of examples of people who, with all their supposed technical abilities, have fallen into the error of explaining the Qur'an with a twisted approach. The founders of many perverse movements and sects seem proficient in their fields, but are in fact devoid of the knowledge and comprehension bestowed by God. These people have distanced themselves and their ignorant and mindless followers from the true practice of Islam.
Moreover, the idolaters (mushrikun) of Mecca during the Prophet Muhammad's (saas) time, who read, but did not understand and therefore rejected the Qur'an, are clear examples that simply knowing Arabic is not enough to comprehend the Qur'an.
A most important rule in receiving the ability of understanding from God is to fear Him and be sincere. It would not be possible to receive such comprehension while indulging solely in the pleasures of this world. If one's approach toward the Qur'an were made in a judgmental spirit, with a purpose and perspective that would displease God, then this would in turn lead to faulty understanding and interpretation. Someone who indulges in his own desires will not have the right state of mind to conquer the true spirit of the Qur'an and explore its finer points, mysteries and depths. Someone who follows his own desires will lack the ability to reason, and so will only be able to interpret the verses from a very superficial point of view. Moreover, he will fail to see the Divine miracles of the Qur'an.
Besides, a person who follows his baser self will be inclined to interpret the Qur'an according to his own whims and convenience, so it will not be possible for him to find the true meanings of the verses as they are revealed by God. It is stated in the Qur'an how a self-absorbed person is incapable of true understanding:
Have you seen him who has taken his whims and desires to be his god? Will you then be his guardian? Do you suppose that most of them hear or understand? They are just like cattle. Indeed they are even more astray! (Surat al-Furqan: 43-44)
People like that find it quite difficult to contemplate the Qur'an. They might even be incapable of understanding subjects that others consider to be perfectly elementary. They cannot establish the necessary connections between verses, or between verses and events. As a result of their lack of intelligence, they will imagine that those verses are contradictory. Their minds are so closed that they become less than cattle in that regard.
Lack of Thinking
It says in the Qur'an that, in order to make a sound interpretation of its contents, one has to think about and contemplate it thoroughly. If the Qur'an is viewed superficially and read as if it were just another ordinary book, then the true benefits of this endless source of wisdom will not surface. In the Qur'an, God constantly invites man to use his reason and to think. Thinking, using one's reason, and making an effort to try and grasp the meanings, finer points, mysteries and miracles of the Qur'an are essential if one is to truly appreciate it. The Qur'an reveals to everyone information about himself, the purpose behind his creation, the true nature of this world, the reasons for what goes on around him, along with many other subjects concerning him and his surroundings. Accordingly, one should try to evaluate himself, his surroundings and the events he experiences in the light of the verses of the Qur’an, to see the wisdom in these events and strive to understand the Qur'an by thinking deeply on all of these. It is stated in the Qur'an that it was revealed to those who reflect:
This is the path of your Lord – straight. We have
made the Signs clear for people who remember. (Surat al-An'am: 126)
…In this way We make Our Signs clear for people
who reflect. (Surah Yunus: 24)
Since the verses have been revealed only for those who reflect, it is
clear that those who do not do so will not comprehend the meanings of
any of the verses in the Qur'an.
It is a fact that a person's life is filled with numerous lessons he
learns from the events he experiences within himself and in his surroundings.
God sent down the Qur'an as a guide that shows people how to interpret the lessons in
their lives and how they should react once they have understood them.
Therefore, the Qur'an is a guiding light that structures a person's daily
life and explains each moment of his existence. One can only come to the
true meaning of the Qur'an if one reads it with the proper contemplation
that God, the Possessor of infinite knowledge and wisdom, deserves. It
has already been stated in a Qur'anic verse that the Qur'an is a book
that one should contemplate seriously and use as a source of guidance
"It is a Book We have sent down to you, full of blessing, so
let men of understanding ponder its Signs and take heed." (Surah
Sad: 29). Yet again, in another verse,
the importance of genuinely thinking about the Qur'an has been emphasized:
Do they not ponder these words (of God)? Has anything
come to them that did not come to their ancestors the previous peoples?
(Surat al-Mu'minun: 68)
The Qur'an is the source of limitless and superior knowledge because
it has been revealed by God, the Lord of all the Worlds. The Qur'an covers
countless topics, from the attributes of God to the wonders of creation,
from the intricacies of the human soul to the facts and mysteries of the
universe and the Hereafter, and so on. So the appreciation of such vast
amounts of information encased in such a pure and essential language can
only be possible with a combination of deep thought, awareness, attention
to detail, a sincere heart and a strong conscience.
Arrogance and Superiority
Arrogance will prevent anyone from understanding the Qur'an. Since an
arrogant person considers himself to be superior, he will not possess
the necessary humility and awareness needed to approach the Qur'an properly.
He will be unable to bear to see the verses that remind a servant his
weaknesses and the fact that God is the One Who has given him everything
he has ever owned and all of his attributes. He cannot bring himself to
receive the warnings, follow the given commandments, distance himself
from what is forbidden or surrender to the wisdom of God. His pride and
assumed superiority prevent him from doing so. That is the reason why
he will see the Qur'an as an obstacle to his character, which is based on
arrogance. He will fight with all his might to seek ways to contradict
the Qur'an. In so doing he will argue about the verses. It has been stated
in the Qur'an that those with pride cannot comprehend its verses:
I will divert from My Signs all those who are
arrogant in the earth without any right. If they see every Sign, they
will not believe in it. If they see the way of right guidance, they will
not take it as a way. But if they see the way of error, they will take
that as a way. That is because they denied Our Signs and paid no attention
to them. (Surat al-A'raf: 146)
Who could do greater wrong than someone who is
reminded of the Signs of his Lord and then turns away from them, forgetting
all that he has done before? We have placed covers on their hearts, preventing
them from understanding it, and heaviness in their ears. Though you call
them to guidance, they will nonetheless never be guided. (Surat al-Kahf:
57)
Arrogance is a tool for viewing one's own intelligence, culture and knowledge
as superior. So the accomplishments of an arrogant person, such as his
academic career, culture and expertise, will actually serve to distance
him from the Qur'an. The unwise claims made by seeming experts or intellectuals
regarding the Qur'an are proof of the fact that pride prevents anyone
from truly acknowledging the Qur'an. This sort of people are described
in verses:
Certainly those who argue about the Signs of God
without any authority having come to them have nothing in their breasts
except for pride which they will never be able to vindicate. Therefore
seek refuge with God. He is the All-Hearing, the All-Seeing. (Surat al-Mu'min:
56)
Who hears the Signs of God recited to him and
then persists in his arrogance just as if he had never heard them. Give
him the news of a painful punishment. (Surat al-Jathiyah: 8)
So we can conclude that in order to understand the Qur'an, one has to
have the attributes of modesty, humility and obedience, and show total
submission to God with the awareness that one is nothing before His greatness.
Trying to Interpret the Qur'an with Old Traditions and Innovations Incompatible with the Qur’an and the Sunnah
One of the greatest mistakes made when trying to interpret the Qur'an is making use of hearsay, innovations and superstitions from one's forefathers and of old traditions which are claimed to be the words of religion, but which in fact have no place in the Qur’an or the Sunnah of the Prophet (saas). People who do that follow false beliefs rather than the Qur'an, and at the same time try to adapt the Qur'an to those perverted beliefs, in their own eyes. Their twisted mentality has been described in the Qur'an:
When they are told, 'Follow what God has sent down to you,' They say, 'We are following what we found our fathers doing.' What, even though their fathers did not understand a thing and were not guided! (Surat al-Baqarah: 170)
This mistaken interpretation, seen among some sections of the society, puts forward a morality that is completely different from and contradictory to the Islamic one. This model, which is sometimes presented under the name of Islam, in fact has no relation whatsoever with the true religion, ethics and lifestyle that are described in the Qur'an and practiced by the Prophet (saas).
Such people try to give the impression that they base what they say on the Qur'an when trying to authenticate their ideas, interpretations, judgments and applications that are, in truth, far from anything the Qur'an actually represents and have no place in the Sunnah of the Prophet (saas). Yet, they cannot put together any logical explanation for their unfounded claims. No matter how hard they try, anyone with common sense can see through their ridiculous explanations.
The situation of people who are far from realizing the true meaning of the Qur'anic verses and yet try to turn people away from the right path with uneducated explanations is reported in the Qur’an:
But there are some people who trade in distracting tales to misguide people from God's Way knowing nothing about it and to make a mockery of it. Such people will have a humiliating punishment. When Our Signs are recited to such a person, he turns away arrogantly as if he had not heard, as if there was a great weight in his ears. So give him news of a painful punishment. (Surah Luqman: 6-7)
Inability to Understand the Scientific Qur'anic Verses
Many scientific facts are mentioned either directly or indirectly in
the Qur'an. Many topics, from the creation phases of the universe, human
beings and the formation of rain to the movement of continents are mentioned
as proof of the perfection and superiority of God's creation. Nevertheless,
obviously the Qur'an is not a book of science. In the Qur'an, scientific
information is sometimes mentioned in a clear, lucid language, and at
other times it is explained by means of comparisons, indications or concealed
language. Being unable to realize the wisdom in such verses, some prejudiced
people, who do not possess the necessary basic knowledge of science and
scientific progress, nor a subtle comprehension, end up opposing the Qur'an.
Still, the people of the 21st century witnessed, through the use of the
latest technological observations, experiments and research, the miraculous
verification of various scientific facts pointed to in the Qur'an. Furthermore,
science was dominated by hearsay and unproven theories until the last
two centuries when all the while the Qur'an, written some 1,400 years
ago, was drawing attention to scientific facts that have finally been
proven today.
Numerous scientific topics, such as the Big Bang, the expansion of the
universe, the relativity of time, continental motion etc., were mentioned
in the Qur'an when it was revealed nearly 1,400 years ago. (For a detailed
analysis see Miracles of the Qur'an by Harun Yahya.) The secret of these
verses remained a mystery for Muslims, who had been reading them for years.
However, Muslims expressed faith in all of these verses, which they knew
to contain many secrets and great wisdom, without understanding their
true meaning, just as they believe without any doubt that the Qur'an is
the "truth" (haq) revealed by God. Those who use their reason
and are capable of intense thought perceive each verse as a part of the
endless knowledge of God. It is true that there remain some verses that
have yet to be fully explained and whose mysteries have still to be revealed.
Such verses are a source of excitement and enthusiasm for the true believer.
This concealed knowledge also makes them feel totally enclosed within
the boundless wisdom of God.
Those with ulterior motives commonly try to cast doubt on those verses
which have not yet been explained by the current standards of science
and technology. In the Qur'an it is said of those people:
Then when they arrive He (God) will say, 'Did you
deny My Signs even though you did not have proper knowledge of them. What
were you doing?' (Surat an-Naml: 84)
People like that, who approach the Qur'an with prejudice,
view verses, which their limited intelligence and knowledge fail to make
immediately clear, as evidence of supposed inconsistency, as their real purpose
is seeking contradictions in the Qur'an. Just as there were verses which
had remained a mystery since the revelation of the Qur'an until it became
possible to explain them thanks to recent scientific developments, there
may be still more verses waiting to be clarified that will remain in the
shadows until future scientific discoveries. For instance, the Qur'an
gives indications of possible matter and scent transfer. Even though these
may appear to be impossible with today's technology, such ideas have already
made an appearance in science fiction. The verses related to these ideas
in the Qur'an are:
- A person of knowledge in the company of the Prophet Solomon (as) brings
Queen Saba's throne from her palace, thousands of miles away:
He (Solomon) said, 'Council! Who among you will
bring me her throne before they come to me in submission?'
An ifreet of the jinn said, 'I will bring it to
you before you get up from your seat. I am strong and trustworthy enough
to do it.'
He who possessed knowledge of the Book said, 'I
will bring it to you before your glance returns to you.' And when he (Solomon)
saw it standing firmly in his presence, he said, 'This is part of my Lord's
favour to test me to see if I will give thanks or show ingratitude. Whoever
gives thanks only does so to his own gain. Whoever is ungrateful, my Lord
is Rich Beyond Need, Generous.' (Surat an-Naml: 38-40)
- The Prophet Jacob (as) senses the presence of his son, the Prophet Joseph (as),
from miles away:
And when the caravan went on its way, their father
said, 'I can smell Joseph's scent! You probably think I have become senile.'(Surah
Yusuf: 94)
It is only natural that some of the verses in the Qur'an, which is valid
till the Day of Judgment and contains information that is applicable to
all times, are not understandable when they are interpreted only by using
the currently available technological data, which have still not reached
the required level. However, as further advances are made, the "overlapping"
meanings in the scientific Qur'anic verses are becoming clearer.
Trying to Interpret the Qur'an According to the Flawed Values of the Established
Order
There are those who live by modern-day as well as social standards, who accept the rules applied by the majority as absolute facts and use them to try and interpret the Qur'an. People like this make up the majority of those who try to object to the Qur'an, even though they are the least educated and cultured. It is possible to come across such people in every profession and part of society. They make up a majority, who do not think too deeply or possess a certain world-view, and are obsessed only with worldly pursuits and are only focused on their livelihood. Since they seek simple pleasures, small calculations and profits, they imagine that the Qur'an would limit their so-called freedom, alter their simple lifestyles or expectations, and the order to which they are accustomed. Therefore, they try to oppose the Qur'an with their primitive logic.
Members of this group make the same irrational comments about the Qur'an that they have heard from others, ideas originally not their own. They usually make unreasonable and ignorant remarks about the Qur'an using sentences that begin with such words as, "In the 21st century…", "In our day and age…", "In the space age….", "In the West…." , and so on.
They propose that the lifestyle described in the Qur'an and that of our own time are incompatible, and that the former is in fact outdated. From that perspective they subsequently make false claims concerning the Qur'an. For example, they attempt to criticize the commandments of the Qur’an, in their own eyes, making such irrational and illogical claims as that fasting and prayer interfere with the pace of the modern lifestyle, that the Islamic ban on interest cannot be practiced under current economic conditions and even that the prohibition of adultery in this day and age is not possible.
They apply superficial logic and display great ignorance when addressing the topics of the prayers, commands, and prohibitions in the Qur'an. They introduce arguments about the wisdom in some commands which they do not understand or the verses that they cannot comprehend. Worse still, they defend their illogical claims with great ferocity.
They accept society's general lifestyle and world-view, which they refer
to as "the facts of life," as the absolute truth and seek errors
and discrepancies in the Qur'an by taking them as a point of reference.
The notions they use as criteria have no actual scientific or logical
worth. The concepts that they assume to be the absolute truth, "the
facts of life" or the requirements of the modern age, are in fact
illusions with which they only deceive themselves and provide psychological
support for one another.
We are informed, in the Qur'an, of the twisted path of these people,
who gather all their strength from being part of the majority and think
that they are on the right path since they are in harmony with everyone
else:
If you obeyed most of those on earth, they would
misguide you from God's Way. They follow nothing but conjecture. They
are only guessing. (Surat al-An'am: 116) |
